Benefits of Agent-Based vs Agentless Monitoring

Benefits of Agent-Based vs Agentless Monitoring

Server Monitoring

Benefits of Monitoring Using an Agent Over Agentless

Understand the key differences between agent-based and agentless monitoring in Cloudmon, so you can choose the right method for each device in your environment.

Overview

Cloudmon supports two fundamentally different approaches to monitoring: agent-based and agentless. Both methods collect performance, availability, and health data from monitored devices, but they differ in how they connect, how frequently they collect data, and the depth of visibility they provide. Choosing the right method for each device type is one of the most important decisions when deploying Cloudmon.

In most environments, both methods are used together. Agent-based monitoring is deployed on critical servers, desktops, laptops, and virtual machines where deep visibility and fast detection are required. Agentless monitoring using SNMP or WMI is used for network devices, less critical servers, and any device where installing an agent is impractical or unnecessary.

Side-by-Side Comparison

CapabilityAgent-BasedAgentless (SNMP / WMI)
Downtime detection speedWithin 25 seconds via liveness monitoringDetected at the next polling interval (typically minutes)
Minimum polling interval1 second (configurable per device)Longer intervals, dependent on SNMP or WMI polling configuration
Software installation requiredYes, Cloudmon agent installed on the deviceNo, it uses SNMP or WMI protocols via a probe
Process and service monitoringFull process and service monitoring with per-process CPU, memory, PID, and installation pathLimited. WMI supports some process visibility on Windows; SNMP does not
Installed software inventoryFull software inventory visible in the Installed Software tabNot available
Automated remediationSupported. Runbooks can be executed automatically on the agent when an alarm firesRunbooks can be run on the probe or controller, not on the monitored device directly
Digital Experience Monitoring (DEM)Supported. DEM requires the agent to measure application experience from the user's deviceNot available
Hyper-V monitoringSupported. Hyper-V can only be monitored via the Cloudmon agentNot available
Cloud server supportSupported. The agent can be installed on cloud instances (AWS EC2, Azure VM, etc.)Supported for SNMP-enabled cloud appliances; WMI requires probe connectivity
ScalabilityRequires individual installation on each device; most suitable for critical devicesScales easily to large device counts without installation; ideal for broad coverage
Resource overhead on monitored deviceMinimal. The agent uses a small amount of CPU and memory on the hostNone, as no software runs on the monitored device
Supported platformsWindows, Linux (CentOS, Ubuntu, Debian, Fedora, Red Hat, SUSE, Amazon Linux), macOS, AndroidAny SNMP-enabled device; WMI for Windows servers only

When to Use Agent-Based Monitoring

Agent-based monitoring is the right choice when you need the highest level of visibility, the fastest possible detection, or features that are only available with an agent installed on the device.

Critical servers and infrastructure: For servers where downtime has significant business consequences, such as database servers, application servers, and domain controllers, agent-based monitoring detects outages and reboots within 25 seconds via liveness monitoring. This is far faster than agentless polling, which detects issues only at the next polling interval. Financial institutions, healthcare providers, and e-commerce platforms running time-sensitive workloads benefit most from this speed.

High-frequency monitoring requirements: The Cloudmon agent supports polling intervals as short as 1 second, providing real-time visibility into CPU, memory, disk, and network metrics. This granularity is not achievable with SNMP or WMI polling. IT admins can enable 1-second polling for critical servers and use longer intervals of up to 1 minute for less critical devices, balancing detail with resource efficiency.

Automated remediation: When a threshold is breached on an agent-monitored device, Cloudmon can automatically execute a remediation script on that device without manual intervention. For example, a high CPU alarm can trigger a script to kill the offending process or restart a service. This automated remediation capability is only available on agent-monitored devices, as agentless monitoring can only run scripts on the probe or controller.

Process, service, and software visibility: The agent provides full visibility into all running processes with per-process CPU and memory consumption, all installed software, and all active Windows services. This level of detail is essential for compliance auditing, capacity planning, and diagnosing performance issues at the application layer. None of this is available through SNMP or WMI at the same depth.

Digital Experience Monitoring: DEM requires the Cloudmon agent to be installed on end-user devices such as laptops and desktops. The agent measures application experience from the user's perspective across device, LAN, WAN, ISP, and application layers. There is no agentless equivalent for DEM.

Hyper-V environments: Hyper-V servers can only be monitored using the Cloudmon agent. If you run Hyper-V virtualization in your environment, agent-based monitoring is mandatory for those hosts.

When to Use Agentless Monitoring

Agentless monitoring is the right choice when you need broad coverage across many devices, when installing software on target devices is impractical, or when the monitored devices do not support agent installation.

Network devices: Routers, switches, firewalls, and other network infrastructure devices do not support agent installation. SNMP is the standard protocol for monitoring these devices, giving visibility into availability, interface traffic, CPU, memory, and device-specific metrics through over 4,500 built-in templates in Cloudmon.

Large-scale deployments: In environments with hundreds or thousands of devices, agentless monitoring is more practical and cost-effective than deploying agents individually on every device. SNMP credentials are added once and applied across many devices via templates, making it straightforward to scale coverage quickly.

Less critical desktops and laptops: For devices where the depth of visibility provided by an agent is not required, SNMP monitoring provides the essential availability and performance metrics without the overhead of agent installation and maintenance.

Windows servers via WMI: For Windows servers where an agent cannot be installed, WMI provides a rich set of performance metrics including CPU, memory, disk, and network, plus support for 12 Windows application templates covering Active Directory, DHCP, IIS, SQL Server, Exchange, and more. WMI monitoring requires a Windows probe and a domain administrator credential.

    • Related Articles

    • Agent Vs Agentless Monitoring in cloudmon

      Attribute Agent-based Monitoring Agentless Monitoring – SNMP, WMI, TCP, ICMP Methodology Deploy the Cloudmon Agent on each server that requires monitoring. Cloudmon uses Probes to monitor IP network endpoints and devices in the network such as ...
    • Server Monitoring

      Servers Server Monitoring Monitor servers, virtual machines, and Windows infrastructure across your environment. Cloudmon supports agent-based and agentless monitoring, giving you the flexibility to cover every server regardless of how it is managed. ...
    • What are the different modes of monitoring in cloudmon?

      There are three modes of monitoring: agent-based and agentless monitoring
    • How to configure a Monitoring Profile for an agent in cloudmon?

      By default, the monitoring profile default is configured for every entity. The default profile includes all the metrics for monitoring and can be modified if required. Follow the steps to change the profile from default to the user-defined profile ...
    • How to add "tags" to an agent in cloudmon?

      To add Tags, Navigate to Settings > Monitoring > Hosts/Agents. Locate the specific agent, click Edit under the Actions of the particular agent, and add the desired tags. On the other hand, you can also add an 'Tags' by navigating to Agents>All ...